White Like Me
We talk a lot about America and its businesses being world leaders, but I have to say that I am extremely disappointed that, as a result of elections last week, the U.S. Senate will include not a single African-American member. That should be of major concern no matter what party you prefer.
The three African-American candidates--all of which happened to be Democrats this time--lost, and the single black incumbent is retiring. According to CNN, "only six black senators have ever served in the U.S. Senate: three Republicans and three Democrats, including President Barack Obama." That raises a mighty serious question about how we as Americans view leaders from minority populations.
And sadly, this problem extends to the power positions within associations and nonprofits as well. I try not to roll my eyes when I hear someone say, "We can't find any minority members willing (or qualified or whatever) to run for the board," or "we don't have many minority members, so our board tends to stay white." Really? I don't see recruitment problems at associations whose names depict a certain race, gender, or other defining demographic--those leadership pipelines appear to operate quite well.
Minorities exist in every field and profession, but maybe they haven't heard about your association, or feel welcome there, or feel like it is relevant enough. Or maybe not enough effort has been made to focus in on tracking down these types of perhaps behind-the-scene members or nonmembers and finding methods to help them engage in ways that they find valuable.
Like the federal face we are now showing the world, we have failed to reflect the true diversity of our nation and our business community. As both parties gear up for the 2012 presidential race, which will again feature wonk talks about the tipping-point capability of voting minority citizens, I hope discussions about current leadership pipelines (or lack thereof) for African Americans and minorities will become much messier and disruptive. And I'm hoping that discussion carries over into the association community because we must take this issue more seriously.
Census data show that an estimated 14% of our population is Black, and that number is growing. We must purge the old excuses about minorities' "apathy toward associations" and try new thinking, new models, new outreach efforts. The world is predominantly nonwhite, and they are watching--both our country and its business community.
| | Permalink |
Comments
Thank you for writing this fantastic post.
Shelly
Posted by: Shelly Alcorn, CAE | November 10, 2010 11:20 AM
And yet despite all the good ASAE is doing with its diversity and inclusion initiatives, the 11/10 issue of the magazine's CEO to CEO features eight Caucasians: seven men and one female. How does that happen?
Posted by: Jeffrey Cufaude | November 10, 2010 11:47 AM
Kristin, you make excellent points. As someone who has been there, done that, and who has seen this problem over, and over, and over again, I believe that the only way this changes is to make it someone's job on staff - and that someone has to have real and influential authority.
No one said it was easy to do this, but unless there is someone on staff who is advocating for this every single day, it just doesn't happen. It's too easy to pay lip service to diversity. Sure, it sounds good, and you can find data to support the value of it, but until the board makes it a goal, and there is staffing behind that goal, it just won't happen. And I don't think one person is enough because that person will eventually be marginalized. There needs to be a champion, but everyone has to be held accountable.... the meetings people to ensure the keynotes aren't all white (or whatever the challenge is), the publications staff to ensure the interviewees are diverse, HR staff to ensure a diversity of staff - and staff working groups, marketing/communications staff to ensure that their messages, testimonials, ads, all reflect diversity, program staff to ensure the leadership pipeline is getting populated from the start.
Really - this takes a village and a champion, and a board that is willing to hold itself accountable. Diversity doesn't just start happening on its own.
Posted by: Kristi Donovan | November 12, 2010 8:04 AM