« Diversity | Main | Meetings Overseas--When Members Won't Go »

Honest Words about Diversity--for a Change

I've lost count of how many diversity programs I've attended in my career, but I thought this morning's General Session on "Looking Through the Lens of Others" was especially terrific. Here are some samples I valued:

--Nadira Hira, the impressive 20-something journalist for Fortune, is an articulate mouthpiece for young and younger workers. Her advice: "Be authentic. Don't try to pretend you're diverse when you're not." In other words, forget the BS.

--Doug Klein, executive director of the Association for Conflict Resolution, noted that the reason race or ethnic-based professional and trade organizations still exist is "because there's a need not being met" by the broader association in that profession or trade.

I immediately recalled a conversation I had with--of all people--actor Louis Gossett Jr. backstage at the last Nation’s Capital Distinguished Speakers Series. He had told me about the evolution of racism from a black professional's perspective, and I had asked him if the time had finally come for the association community to make a commitment to facilitate mergers of broad-based associations with similar niche groups grounded in race or gender as well as the profession or trade, such as the Society of Professional Journalists with the National Association of Black Journalists.

The actor, who founded and actively guides a New Orleans-based foundation to help at-risk youths, said no. He urged associations to instead focus on youth--the next generation of workers--rather than try to overcome the prejudices of the current workforce, which he said was essentially fruitless. Klein's comment today seemed to reiterate those conclusions on an organizational level.

--The always-blunt, always-superb Patti Digh laments that "people aren't focused on retention at all. They just want to 'get 'em in the door.' This lack of "diversity succession planning" was raised at ASAE & The Center's last diversity forum. Basically, no one knows how to do it or even what such a plan looks like. Perhaps that's a project or research idea for our Diversity Committee or for a select task force.

--Co-moderator Cokie Roberts noted, "At some point we have to be the token," but then that representative should "bring others in." That implies a responsibility, not a choice, on the part of the, say, female executive about actively attracting other smart, accomplished women into the organization.

I have mixed feelings on that. I think we should do what we can to attract all smart, accomplished people to our association IF that organization is best set up to leverage their talents and knowledge for the benefit of the members. I'm uncomfortable screening candidates primarily because they look like me or share a cultural commonality. That said, I'm likely to be a more successful recruiter within those desired demographics because of that reality. Comments? I need to think about this more.

A "Say what?" moment: Patti was called by a company that said its white employees were putting nooses on the lockers of black employees. Patti said she could design an intervention, etc. The response? "We're thinking of a two-hour training session."

Quotables from the General Session:

"We talk about diversity as an end in itself, not what that brings us.... Diversity is not a problem to be fixed.... We've damned ourselves in this country by being too PC [politically correct]. You can't know if you're talking to yourself only." --Patti Digh

"We're afraid of [diversity], even though we know it's good for us."--consultant Steve Hanamura

"Powerful" and "moving"--just some of the high praise I heard about the "Peer Perspectives" video clips of diverse association executives.


|

Comments

One of the best moments for me was when Steve began speaking, and how different it felt to me compared to the camera panning on his face at the beginning. My god-daughter is blind and I was thinking of her when I watched him on the screen. But then when he launched into some very funny observations I asked myself again how often do I, and we all, judge 'books by their covers' and set our expectations in well-intentioned ways ... but we are erroneously thinking that someone who seems different from us is so much more different than they really are from us. This was a guy I'd love to hear more from or have a beer with. Not a profound statement, but the entire session was wonderful from the perspective of a lumpy middle aged white guy ... !

I'll admit to skipping the opening session because I'm not a morning person and I'm also a naughty meeting attendee (apparently). So I've enjoyed reading the coverage on Acronym.

One thing in particular stood out to me:

"[Gossett Jr] urged associations to instead focus on youth--the next generation of workers--rather than try to overcome the prejudices of the current workforce, which he said was essentially fruitless."

Wow. Powerful quote, I think. Also sad. Why is this even still an issue? How could it not be a good idea to include everyone's ideas and perspectives? Who among us is really THAT sure that s/he has all the answers?

Elizabeth, thanks for mentioning that you're not a morning person. Lots of association people hate mornings but are afraid to let anybody know, for fear of appearing different.
It's how you use your time, not what time you use, that really matters.

Kevin - you might be interested to know more about Steve Hanamura - this coming Friday and Saturday, he will compete in a 197-mile (yes, 197 mile) relay race on Mt Hood in Oregon as part of an intergenerational, international team of runners!

One of the absolute pleasures of participating on the panel was meeting all the other panelists - I had known Steve before and share your feeling of wanting to spend time with him - the conversations we all had as a group before the session were amazingly rich for me. Nadira Hira from Fortune magazine and I were immediately making plans for meeting again - I might try to re-gather them for a discussion we could turn into an article for ASAE....

Patti, Thank you so much for sharing that, he is a fascinating guy and I'll certainly look forward to anything that comes from a 'reunion' you have with them!

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)